this post was submitted on 14 Jul 2025
540 points (100.0% liked)
Trippin' Through Time
4841 readers
135 users here now
Tripping' Through Time
A Lemmy community for historic art pieces overhauled into modern memes.
Rules
- Only image uploads allowed
- Only edited, historical images may be shared
- The instance rules of https://lemmy.ca/
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The battle of helm's deep is way better in the movies at least. Battle of gondor.. some parts are better in the books, the whole "ghosts killing everyone" in the movies was a bit cheap. But either way both are great.
Oh and frodo in book > frodo in movie
Hot take, the battles in the book aren't great because Tolkien doesn't want to glorify violence. Half of the fights are like two pages in the books before the point of view character passes out. After realizing that I was kind of disappointed in how "campy early 2000s action movie" the battles in the films are.
There certainly are things I liked better in the books, I remember that much. But when judging entirety of books vs entirety of movies movies were better in my opinion.
(I'm only talking LotR itself ofc)
Yeah the movies have 1 extra thing that puts it way above the books: music
The Hobbit and LOTR books are actually fantastic to listen to as audiobooks. The narrator (at least in the version I had) sings all the songs.
Oh yeah I loved those too. Depends on the narrator I guess as well. But the music in the movies is on a different level.