The hint was the plane
I believe it's called "Stop using AI art in order to get people to guess a song"
this post was submitted on 13 Apr 2024
20 points (100.0% liked)
The Lyrics Game
872 readers
2 users here now
Anybody can post a challenge.
The rules of the game are simple, take any song you like from any genre you want, put the lyrics through any AI [you may weight lyrics as the AI allows] that you want and post the resulting image here under the post title Name That Song [GENRE]. After 48-72 Hours or if the answer is guessed sooner, edit the post's title to [Solved][Genre] and put the song title and artist (and optionally any highlighted lyrics) in a spoiler tag in the body of the post.
Other than that, enjoy.
Here is a list to a few AI image generators you can use.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
points at the description of entire The Lyrics Game sub
protests in retaliation for artists.
So you would be fine with me "stealing" images "stolen" by google image search then? Perhaps the artists should make private the things they don't want to be "stolen", instead of uploading and showing them in plain, unrestricted public view. Patreon, etc. exists, as does requiring a login, instead of posting their art publicly. After all, by merely viewing the art with your web browser, you and the computer have already "stolen" the art two or three times by copying and viewing.
Perhaps you should consider supporting artists rather than doing this?
Regardless what you do, you're still stealing art.
AI stole the art from those public posts, they had no way of knowing that it would've been used for this purpose. How are they supposed to show their talent without the world seeing it?
An artist drawing a particular train on the track has stolen from the vision of the engineers and designers that built the train, by interpreting what they see and showing it to the world.
An artist drawing fanart of a character has stolen from the moneymaking, copyrighted and trademarked ip of a company and their artists who designed the character, by showing their interpretation instead of letting the original artists display theirs.
A photographer taking a picture has stolen from the livelihood of the still portrait painter, who's entire career revolves around quickly and accurately painting a scene that is in front of them, something a camera does "perfectly" and "without skill".
In all these cases, the only ones that are shot down on the definition of "stealing" (copyright infrjngement, not the same) are those that replicate what they see to an exacting degree.
Only an AI image that replicates the art of an artist to a confusably exact degree, enough to be falsely and fraudulently passed as the work of said artist, then is used to defraud said artist by being labelled as the artist's work, would be eligible to be considered "stolen".
The point of this sub is merely a guessing game. It is not a moneymaker. If you feel so strongly about this, why are you here?
If you feel you must throw your money at an artist, then by all means, flex your disposable budget that I do not have in a commisssion and post it here when it is done. Have us guess what song this image was inspired by.
I'm here because I didn't realize until you pointed it out it said anything about AI (even though I read the description and didn't see it say AI until you pointed it out), also it's been showing up on my timeline, so I thought I would take a shot about why AI art is bad.
Now for the counterarguments:
Technically, fanart boosts popularity of a show, if companies didn't like it, they would've taken it down almost immediately.
Photography in itself is a form of genuine art. Also, that argument only "works" if an artist was at that location and drew it. Most artists take photos in order to draw what they see in nature. I put works in quotes because the argument really doesn't work, and in fact, professional photography does take skill.
In this sub itself, there have been countless posts copying the Pixar art style, which in your definition is considered "falsely and fraudulently passed as the work of said artist", so your point?
Hey, I don't have money either, but at least I have moral respect for artists who do this for a living, and would support them in any way I could.
Edit: Regardless, after this note I am blocking this community. Hoorah for you I guess, I still don't agree with your decisions.
The Dreamworks animation style is a blatant copy of the Pixar art style, which itself is a smooth textured, cartoony animation style but with 3D that has been done by countless kid's animation series now, and yet, Disney has not slaughtered them all. One can not truly own a "style" in a generic sense like that. Now if one were to make a fake Pixar movie graphic using AI and deliberately mislead people with it by claiming it's an actual Pixar render, that would be "stealing". That's not what is happening here.
Crazy Train?
Good guess, but no.
I've been looking at some of this posts and has anybody gotten the name right at all?
Not yet. There's lots of big train songs, but the real hint is in the rest of the image.
I meant the whole community overall, has anybody correctly ID any of the images? Music has lots of genre across decades. Unless you've heard all music across all genres the chance of IDying the image is very small.
Take a look at the sub. For every image that goes unidentified, another gets identified right away.
Interstate Love Song
by Stone Temple Pilots?
Nope. Good guess, but nope.
Rock and Roll Train - ACDC?
Nope
Folsom Prison Blue by Johnny Cash Or the song it borrowed heavily (stole) from Crescent City Blues by Gordon Jenkins
Nope
Runaway Train - Soul Asylum
Nope
Freight Train - Alan Jackson
Nope
Locomotive Breath by Jethro Tull.
Nope
Terror train - Demons and Wizards
nope
How in Jerry Garcia's name has no one said Casey Jones by The Grateful Dead? I don't even think it's the right guess tbh, but damn. 😂
Nope
Dreams by the Cranberries? Or any other song by them, really.
nope
Train Kept Rollin
nope
Mystery Train?
Nope
Folsom Prison Blues?
Nope
City of New Orleans?
Nope
Peace Train
Nope.
Long Black Train by Josh Turner
Nope
Quad City DJ's - C'Mon 'N Ride It (The Train)
Nope
Princess of the night by Saxon?
view more: next ›