I’ve had good luck with Garuda after nearly two decades on Ubuntu and its derivatives.

So much so that I moved my work os to it, despite the gaming bent.

The only one i used is CachyOS so its the best out of the three

My best experience with gaming on linux was on nobara(gnome)

I’ve quite enjoyed Tuxedo OS on my gaming rig. Worked right out of the box with every game I’ve thrown at it with my Nvidia GPU.

I'm quite new to linux gaming, and so far I've only used CachyOS and EndeavourOS.
I have a dedicated gaming computer with an AMD GPU, only one hard drive and no critical data. Both were easy to install but I just used the default options, didn't try to do anything complicated.
Performance-wise, I didn't see any difference (but I don't care enough to run benchmarks so maybe one gives me 3% more FPS than the other). I play in 1440p.
I've had a few mishaps on CachyOS regarding updates (2 years ago) so I tried EndeavourOS and it's all been smooth since then.

I guess the answer to your questions depends a lot on your gaming style and on what is important to you.
If you're like me, you just want it to work and you do nothing else than gaming, then all the distros mentioned in this thread are about as good.
If you want to squeeze that extra 2 FPS, or if you want to game on older hardware, or if you also use that computer as part of your homelab... then there are going to be differences.
You might want to consider giving us more information on your needs/projects so that we can adjust our answers.

Welcome to linux gaming :)

I made the mistake of installing Kubuntu 24.04 when I wiped Windows off my gaming machine. I regret it. It's not SO bad, but I don't like having Snaps shoved down my throat. Otherwise it's OK. And you still have great support online and tons of documentation.

The best alternative in my opinion would be Arch via the Endeavor OS distro. It's easier to install than standard Arch, it has an increasingly large community, awesome documentation (Arch Wiki), and is packages are up to date. And I think it's a rolling release? (Correct me if I'm getting)

Otherwise if you want stability, I'd suggest Debian stable. They just released a new stable version not too long ago so it's not too outdated. It's incredibly stable. However, over time the software isn't updated to the latest releases for stability's sake. It takes two years before they release a new version kinda like Ubuntu LTS.

Edit:

I should add that with flatpaks you don't really need the latest and greatest packages in your distro anymore. It's not really a big deal if you're not on the latest GNOME or KDE Plasma. It still works fine. Application wise you can get all the latest apps on Flathub anyway, regardless of distro or how outdated your Linux is.

If I need to reinstall, I'll be using Debian (stable). I don't want any hassle.

I've been pretty happy with Garuda Linux, Arch based. You'd be fine with near any of them though. Fedora base is amazing and stable and as well as the Arch based systems I use.

In the end it comes down to your hardware and what kind of gaming you want to do.
AMD gpus seem to work the best next with Intel GPUs. Nvidia can certainly work and be stable but has some drawbacks with Wayland from what I remember. (Maybe have been fixed?)

Anticheat is a crap shoot sometimes

I use Zorin OS, which is based on Ubuntu. Never had to set anything extra up, just installed Steam and everything worked.

Windows, lol

I used EndeavourOS for about a year and a half with no issues at all. Currently testing Nobara as I wanted to try something different. Again, no issues at all.

Just my opinions as I am still a Linux noob (been using it on and off for the last 15 years, but only on old hardware, and I made A LOT of mistakes):

Handheld? --> Bazzite

Desktop? --> openSUSE Tumbleweed