I switched to Organic Maps on Android. I'm still figuring out how to make it convenient (some apps seem to prefer trying to open with Google Maps which is now disabled) but it works on Android Auto and gets me to destination just fine.
this post was submitted on 16 Feb 2025
343 points (100.0% liked)
Technology
67422 readers
3660 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related news or articles.
- Be excellent to each other!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, this includes using AI responses and summaries. To ask if your bot can be added please contact a mod.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
- Accounts 7 days and younger will have their posts automatically removed.
Approved Bots
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I tried this on a trip a couple days ago and had to go back to Google. It wasn't giving me street names or exits in the navigation. It'd say take the next right instead of take exit 17 for example. Completely missed a fork and didn't tell me which way to go. Google has issues too but first impressions for organic was not positive.
For car navigation use Magic Earth. It’based on Openstreetmap too, Han has the best routing algorithm I found so far (yes, better than Google).
I'll give it a try for the ride home in a couple days.
I've been using Tom Tom for a week and I'm gonna say, it's doing the job. It could be better though. I'm hoping that some better app comes along otherwise I'll just go back to Waze and use a dummy account on it or something.
I also recommend downloading StreetComplete, which lets you contribute to the OpenStreetMaps database.
Here WeGo is a good alternative that can work fully offline too.
If you open the android settings for Organic Maps (where you adjust permissions), there should be one called "Open by Default" or something like that. Just add all the links that are presented there.
Organic map is crazy fast. I just wish it has trafic data but after a few weeks using it, that's not a big difference in the end.
Traffic isn't too bad where I'm at, but I find myself missing satelite images and streetview, both for exploring and locating garage entrances or anything else. Having said that, and thanks to my buddies here on Lemmy, I successfully eliminated over half of my proprietary phone apps and shoved all the remaining proprietary stuff in a single folder so I would only access it after trying the FOSS alternatives. Anything that has a web portal instead of an app is going next, and that includes Google Maps.
Organic maps is great, OSMand is great if more detail is needed.
Openstreetmaps is an awesome setup just saying ;)
It's cool but I need traffic routing :(
There's some routing in place! It's not perfect everywhere I'll admit, but it's an option. An option owned by the public, improving every day, and more detailed if you want to help 🤗
Just spent 20 minutes finding an updated motor carriers Atlas.
It is spiral bound and laminated pages.
Google maps is handy... But like with all online services . We are at the mercy of license agreement....
Time to start thinking about going back to analog sources of information.
Edit: https://a.co/d/dIsSgha - is the one in getting.
Yes it's an Amazon link... But buy used from an independent seller.
Unfortunately they also go out of date pretty quickly.
OSM is a great option, and you can host it yourself.
That was a fun educational watch seeing the thought process that goes into trying to figure how to interpret the data to make an extension.
Who cares? How often does someone actually see the name of the Gulf when using maps?
Because if Google agrees to that kind of petty shit, you better know they're gonna give your data and position to the government without a blink. De-googling yourself is just common sense at this point.
And every other mapping source out there that currently still labels it Gulf of Mexico will eventually change it to Gulf of America because that's what it is recognized by the federal government. Name changes never prevent people from using the well-established name, a majority of users on X still refer to it as Twitter. It will always be Twitter.
Do you actually believe that Google has not been providing data to the government since the beginning?
Um no.
A state can decide what it names itself or names a part of itself (e.g. Black Lives Matter Plaza). The story of Ukraine illustrates this.
But geographers and cartographers don't decide what to name a place or get orders from states by fiat (unless the mapper is a state agent working for a department) They name things based on what they're called.
The gulf is known to most of the world and the International Hydrographic Organization as Golfo de México or in English, Gulf of Mexico, and calling it the Gulf of America (say by Google Maps) is political allegiance signaling, that they are MAGA or MAGA collaborators.
If you want to be spicy you can call it Chalchiuhtlicueyecatl or the House of Chalchiuhtlicue based on the South American deity of the sea. It has a nice ominous Siege of R'lyeh feel that reflects the tempestuous weather of the ocean expanse.
geographers and cartographers don't decide what to name a place or get orders from states by fiat
Should we also refer to Texas as Mexico since that's what it was called at one time?
And every other mapping source out there that currently still labels it Gulf of Mexico will eventually change it to Gulf of America because that's what it is recognized by the federal government.
The US government doesn't control map charts for the world. The Gulf of Mexico is International water, the US only controls a part of it. Even then, that executive order didn't have that kind of power in itself, google is gladly enabling this shit because it's in their best interest to stay as close to the other oligarchs.
And its not just this, if you think people are De-googling just because they made that change, you're not looking at the big picture.
Do you actually believe that Google has not been providing data to the government since the beginning?
I knew it was happening to some extent but the impact it had on my life was minimal... Now the US government is at war with people like me, it is simply normal that I yeet anything that's linked to those efforts and that I stop using services from mega corporations that will work with Trump to make all of his insane agenda come true.
You act like people are overreacting but the truth is we should have done this years ago.
Plus I'm not from the US so at this point and with Google being so close to Trump I trust them as much as I trust Tencent with my data, which is to say not at all.
The government has been at war with everyone in working class for decades. Their sole job is to protect the interests of the oligarchs, blue and red
Do you actually believe that Google has not been providing data to the government since the beginning?
I’m sure they have with hindsight being 20/20, however they are simply giving us all a middle finger now. Have some principles.
They have policy that updates names from official government sources. you people are making petty things are bigger deal.
And how does adding an extension to Google Chrome that visually changes one word on Google Maps suppose to help with that?
I think that it being a Trump decision, people needs to get mad ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
With all the shit that Trump does, it makes more sense to get mad about things that actually matter.
Yet here we are
For the fastest routing, try GraphHopper maps (F-droid), unbeatable in that region. For searching, gmaps is really difficult to beat. Organic maps is OK.