HJF, fuck the industry. I get it, people want to make money and people want the new hawtness. But people really need to stop falling for this shit.
Eat of buffet of dicks, Bicycling Magazine, you astroturfing shitrag. You know what will far outlive 99.9% of cyclists lives? A properly built 32h cartridge bearing disc wheelset. If it were built properly, with double-butted spokes, spoke washers, brass nipples, and stress-relieved spokes, the hubshell and/or rim will fail before a spoke fails*. You know what other carbon fiber wheels had a "lifetime replacement warranty?" Mad Fiber. Yeah, go ahead and look up that mess.
*If you ever broke a spoke, it's because your wheel was built improperly. And no, I'm not talking about intrusion to the point of catastrophic failure. I'll spare you the stories, but even a lot of common intrusions shouldn't even make your wheel flinch.
So the article also goes "into" derailleurs. Who has ever worn out a derailleur, front or rear? I sold a bike with 125,000 miles with the same Deore XT derailleur, Shimano C101 (super low end) front derailleur. The C101 was still going strong, including a decade of intentional neglect just to see when it would quit. I gave up and decided it should be nurtured into its twilight years. Still going strong AFAIK/ last I talked to the new owner. That kit is over 20 years old now, as are the wheels I built.
To paraphrase Chris Rock: "THAT'S what you're supposed to do! What you do you want? A fucking cookie?!" Dear bike industry: don't stand by your stuff in perpetuity? We won't buy it.
I get it. A 9-speed triple drivetrain just ain't the sexy hawtness. And some people don't want to learn how to use TWO shifters. But it's bulletproof, always interchangeble, (mostly/potentially) non-proprietary, and will outlive three of us put together. Bar-end shifters? Sure! Brifters? Yep. Thumbies? That too, friend! Want hydraulics? A plethora of options! Oh, is something not quite right? Switch to friction mode, diagnose it later. Oh, and the parts are cheap if you crashed and need to replace something.
My rant aside, I think Shimano is really onto something with the CUES system, especially the Linkglide system. Sure, it's proprietary, has all the Shimano lock-in it can manage, and that chaps my ass like most things about the modern bike industry. But CUES has a scheduled support lifespan, so one can make an informed decision about group selection. And Linkglide actually delivers on the shifting experience we should have had with Hyperglide. Shimano seem to have recognized what a mess they made and seem to be remedying that with CUES. I have lots of vitriol for Shimano (and SRAM, and Campy), but I can recognize a great product when it comes along. Especially when it's priced for average wage grunts like us.
And let me return to calling out Bicycling. Notice they said nothing about CUES or any of a wide array of quality parts companies often within the buy-once-cry-once territory. Oh, right, because those aren't big-ticket, whizz-bang hawtness. Seriously, if it's in Bicycling, it should always be met prima facie with skepticism, if not outright derision.
Edit: typos, formatting