I mean, the whole point of the show is a critique on fascism.
It's definitely already outstayed its welcome in the USA.
this post was submitted on 01 Apr 2025
357 points (100.0% liked)
Television
1142 readers
414 users here now
Welcome to Television
This community is for discussion of anything related to television or streaming.
Other Communities
Other Television Communities
A community for discussion of anything related to Television via broadcast or streaming.
Rules:
-
Be respectful and courteous to all members.
-
Avoid offensive or discriminatory remarks.
-
Avoid spamming or promoting unrelated products/services.
-
Avoid personal attacks or engaging in heated arguments.
-
Do not engage in any form of illegal activity or promote illegal content.
-
Please mask any and all spoilers with spoiler tags. ****
founded 2 months ago
MODERATORS
We tried and failed, you're on your own now
As a huge fan of the show im glad it's ending too. Anymore multiple seasons of resetting the power balance would kill any interest.
Looking at you, Grays Anatomy
He's probably been approached by one too many chuds that worship their idea of Homelander and that think he is his character.
He is apparently an asshole based on his bar fighting and how he treats his costars.
Perfectly casted.
It’s already ran too long imho. Season 3 amounted to nothing.
Yep I totally lost interest a while ago it got so repetitive
I lost interest during season 2 because it was just too on the nose and obvious, which is odd given that the Ennis original (which I love dearly) is about as unsubtle as you can get.
The other issue was I felt like they largely threw the anti-corporation themes out of the window in favour of making it a superhero show.
I loved the first season, but the way it was evolving in the second just didn't sit well with me.
Yep it steadily declined endless "homelander bad but can't be stopped because reasons"
load more comments
(1 replies)
load more comments
(2 replies)
if I see one of the boys thrown backwards into a wall by a supe and be perfectly fine after ONE MORE TIME...
Yeah, last season wasn't great. Hopefully it'll end strong.
It wont. It's like squeezing an orange, the first few seasons got all the $juice$ now they're wringing a dry husk with tired writers. May as well get Matt Parker and Trey Stone in to wrap up the show at this point.
May as well get Matt Parker and Trey Stone in to wrap up the show at this point.
That would actually be awesome!
load more comments
(1 replies)
Agreed entirely. A show should last only as long as it takes to tell its story. 2-3 seasons is fine. Hell, even limited one season shows are great.
limited one season shows
That's called a "mini series". :)
And BTW, Shogun was the finest thing I've seen in years, maybe ever. My wife and I were drooling for the next episode, week in, week out.
I admit to prejudice. Watched the original mini series many times growing up, read the book three times. My wife's half Japanese, really seems to dislike Japanese anything (🤷🏻), still loved every second of it.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Honestly, it outstayed it's welcome in the final episode of the first season for me.
I don't know sense the fuck the producers have against the story, but fucking or off that far was a waste. They could have just made up their own show and not wasted the money getting the title from Ennis, if they were going to fuck with the core motivation of a central character like that.
Edit:
I have no fucking clue why everyone is all het up and nasty about this I'm not saying people can't enjoy the show, I'm just expressing my opinion, and for some reason people are acting very unpleasant for lemmy.
It's disappointing considering I was very recently arguing that lemmy is unusually respectful of differing opinions. I'm not sure if it's this community that's being hit with unusual incivility, if it's the influx of reddit users not getting that we can be decent to each other while disagreeing, or what.
But, people, remember the human.
Good luck with that aneurysm lol, hope it clears itself up
The comics sucked, the show is a big improvement
Eh, I'm not talking about the quality of the show or comics.
Ennis is pretty well known for having neat ideas and then pissing all over them with hack dialogue and over doing shock scenes. So it wouldn't be hard at all to improve that kind of stuff. And the show had incredible production value, with vastly improved dialogue overall.
But one of the things that way too many adaptations get wrong is fucking with the characters. Butcher, his whole story is his drive to fuck every super in the ass (metaphorically) because of what happened to his wife.
Then, they undid that entire idea at the end of the first season, but kept trying to make Butcher the same guy, with the same behaviors. That's a complete failure to make use of the best parts of what Ennis wrote. The characters, and the core ideas, that's what Ennis is good at.
They had already kinda shifted Huey a good bit via making him american, but they kept his motivation, the core of him. Then they just said "fuck it" and basically mangled Butcher's entire arc.
Like, why bother paying for the rights if you're not going to use the good parts of it?
Same thing happened with Preacher. They dumped a ton of money and time into making a slick, well crafted show, but completely undid the characters motivations and personalities in a single scene.
Ennis may be a hack, but fuck, just do something original if you aren't going to really adapt what matters most.
Devil's advocate: it's a good thing to change things up a bit in an adaptation, both to keep old fans on their toes and maybe come up with new ideas and interpretations.
I had a similar reaction to the s1 ending but I was going to give them the benefit of the doubt that they have some idea of how to work with this.
My big issue came a bit later, when they had Homelander kill Stillwell. To me the main point of the comics was that all the capes were ultimately a non-issue, a theatre. Stilwell was THE most dangerous, evil and scary character, personifying Vogue.
And they replaced him (her, I guess) basically with some comic relief idiots afterwards.
I'm actually okay with changes, when they don't mess up the "spirit" of the characters, and don't totally blow apart a plot
But, yeah, Stillwell, that's such a horrible choice to kill him off at all, much less that way. I had quit watching, but you pick up bits and pieces anyway, and hearing that had made me glad I had already stopped
Man I read those Comics they were garbage. Even pretending that the characters had depth to them in the comics is absurd. The show added so much more depth and interesting aspects to the characters than those stupid Comics did. They were legit bad. The only good part in the comic was the overall world. The show added everything that's special about the concept.
I don't think they are suggesting Butcher had depth. Just that they think the core of the characters and what made them interesting was changed needlessly.
By the way, I also loved the show Preacher and I'm glad they changed it from the comics. But I also understand being upset by it. Sometimes I want adaptations to get the core of the characters right and sometimes I'm totally fine with a more inspired interpretation of a story that I like.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Which is not the point.
The point is that they wasted money on the source material when they could have just done their own thing instead.
load more comments
(3 replies)
lemmy is unusually respectful of differing opinions
Are we talking about the same lemmy?
Yeah. On average, I usually run into a lot less snark and douchebaggery over differing opinions. When it does pop up it's usually over hot button issues where you expect heated responses.
Tbh, even the initial few bad responses here weren't as bad as what I'd see on reddit, but it was just really shocking, especially over a tv show.
I'm used to having disagreements be respectful and thoughtful most of the time, and not just be dismissive. Not that it's always like that, I'm guilty of going too far on some things myself. I just have way more disagreements end with a friendly note.
It's ok to not like a tv show. You don't have to explain yourself to anybody.
Its ok not to agree with a comment, you dont have to share your opinion.
Let me get this straight. You're upset because it's ok to not lile a tv show?
Interesting response.
I believe a show should only run as long as its story warrants it for. Some shows can go however long it wants because it creates its own stories on the go like Doctor Who or Star Trek so they're going to have many series and seasons. But shows like Dexter that start going off its hinges and falls apart because of it going for too long because it had no direction and its story could already be pin-pointed as to when it ends. Those kinds of shows shouldn't be going on at any rate.
If you don't have the creative prowess to keep a show going, tell its story and be done with it.
load more comments
(1 replies)
Homelander kills the shows version of "Trump", then takes complete power. As his first act as president he puts tariffs on the world.
Yeah, don't want a supernatural situation going on.
I mean Sam and Dean could have gone on for another 10 years and I wouldn't have complained.
looking at supernatural, kripkes other creation. when the 2 new showrunners took over, it became nothing more than fan/slashfiction for fans who becames extremely obsessed with the characthers.
Fucking Homelander.
All for it. I rarely find a show beyond sitcom type comedies that isn't dissapointing by season 4. 3 seasons of a good show keeps me simultaneously wanting more but also secretly glad that that's how I'm left feeling. Feel the same way with a really good course at a restaurant.
I always say a show should only run 5 seasons at most, and if it's very popular to just do the occasional mini series.
load more comments
(1 replies)
His glasses look like those novelty ones with the eyes printed on them.
I wish severence would have ended at season 2, exactly the way it did. I'm bracing for dissapointment.
I love the first two seasons of Severance, but even if the third will be bad, it won't affect my feelings towards the first two.
Unless it's GoT season 8 levels of bad, but that's probably not possible.
You say that, but sometimes a continuation is so bad that it like goes back in time and somehow taints your memories.
load more comments
(2 replies)
load more comments
(19 replies)
view more: next ›